Algebra at Proof Level
Given , , , the monic cubic with those roots is . Power sums convert through Newton: , .
Sums give , whose value at is ; , forces and . Every "find this symmetric expression" problem is a two-step: reach , then rebuild. If the problem wants the actual roots, factor the rebuilt polynomial by testing small integers (rational root theorem).
has general term where solve (with for a double root).
has roots : , so . The method IS diagonalization of the companion matrix (Linear Algebra course), which is why it also handles -term recurrences and why a root of modulus dominates growth. Nonhomogeneous recurrences add a particular solution, exactly as for differential equations.
Squaring, clearing denominators, and cross-multiplying can INTRODUCE solutions. Solve, then verify every candidate in the original equation.
squares to ; is a ghost (the left side is , the right ). The clean discipline: record the domain and sign constraints BEFORE squaring ( here), then squaring is reversible on that domain. For nested radicals, isolate one radical per squaring; for forms, multiply by the conjugate.
collapses palindromic polynomials; halves the degree of even polynomials; removes the term of a cubic (Cardano's first step); and tame and . Recognizing WHICH substitution the equation is asking for is the algebra half of the USAMO.
Solve .
Divide by : . With , : , or . gives ; gives complex roots. Real solutions: .
Proofs & Why It Matters
If solve , every solution of is .
Both and satisfy the recurrence (substitute and factor out ). Solutions form a vector space closed under linear combinations, and a solution is determined by — two numbers — so the space is 2-dimensional. and are independent (their initial pairs , are independent for ), hence a basis. For a double root, is the second basis element — verify by substitution, exactly as for in differential equations.
If in lowest terms is a root of with integer coefficients, then and .
Multiply by : . Every term except is divisible by , so , and forces . Symmetrically every term except is divisible by , so . Significance: it makes "factor by finding an integer root" a finite search, and its special case "a monic integer polynomial has no non-integer rational roots" is why is irrational.
Going Deeper: Worked Problems
Find all real triples with , , .
Step 1 — ; ; Newton: gives , so .
Step 2 — the triple consists of the roots of .
Step 3 — all permutations of : six solutions. Symmetric systems never require solving for one variable at a time; rebuild the polynomial and factor.
Solve with , and find .
Step 1 — the fixed point: gives .
Step 2 — shift: satisfies , so .
Step 3 — ; .
Step 4 — check: ✓. Subtracting the fixed point is the recurrence version of "particular solution plus homogeneous," and it works for any with .