Integrating in Three Dimensions
Boxes: integrate straight through. Solids with circular symmetry: CYLINDRICAL coordinates, . Balls and cones: SPHERICAL, . Choosing coordinates to match the region is most of the work.
The ball in spherical: — the middle-school formula, finally proved.
Under : cylindrical gives . Forgetting the extra gives a wrong answer that LOOKS plausible — always write the volume element first.
Nature keeps producing round things — planets, pipes, atoms — and Cartesian boxes fit them badly. Cylindrical and spherical coordinates exist because the volume elements and , once understood, turn week-long integrals into three lines. The hydrogen atom of quantum mechanics is solved in spherical coordinates for exactly this reason.
Volume of the cone from up to over the unit disk (i.e. between and ). Work: — one third of the enclosing cylinder, the classical cone rule, derived rather than remembered.
Proofs & Why It Matters
A small spherical cell has three nearly-perpendicular edges: radial, of length ; along a meridian, an arc of radius subtending , length ; and along a parallel, an arc of radius (the distance to the -axis) subtending , length . The cell volume is the product .
Integrate the element over the ball of radius : . The three integrals separate: .
Going Deeper: Explanations & Worked Problems
The decision tree: does the region have an axis of circular symmetry? If the boundary involves (cylinders, paraboloids, cones over the -axis), use CYLINDRICAL — polar in the floor plane with kept, .
If distances from a single point rule (balls, spherical shells, cones from the origin), use SPHERICAL: (distance from origin), (angle down from the north pole, to ), (longitude), with . Then check the integrand cooperates: in cylindrical; and in spherical. A sphere in Cartesian coordinates costs three nested square-root limits; the SAME sphere in spherical coordinates is a box — coordinates are chosen to make the region a box, because boxes separate.
Volume under above the -plane.
Step 1 — find the floor region: forces , the disk of radius .
Step 2 — write in cylindrical: runs from up to ; the volume element contributes the extra .
Step 3 — innermost (): .
Step 4 — middle (): .
Step 5 — outer (): .
Step 6 — sanity: the enclosing cylinder (radius , height ) has volume ; the paraboloid fills exactly HALF of it — a clean known fact that confirms the arithmetic.
Compute over the ball .
Step 1 — translate: , so , and with the integrand is .
Step 2 — separate the three integrals: .
Step 3 — evaluate each: ; for the middle, substitute , : ; the last is .
Step 4 — multiply: .
Step 5 — symmetry check: by symmetry , and the three must add to ; indeed ✓.